top of page

Supplier Consolidation for Spare Parts: When Fewer Suppliers Actually Means Lower Costs

Skribentens bild: Laura Andersson
Laura Andersson
10 nov.
3 min läsning
Supplier Consolidation for Spare Parts: When Fewer Suppliers Actually Means Lower Costs

Most spare parts supplier lists grow the same way: one urgent order at a time. A part is needed, a new supplier turns out to have it, and that supplier quietly joins the list, never to be formally reviewed again.


Few years later, a plant maintaining a few thousand active parts can easily be buying from several hundred suppliers, most of them used once or twice a year. Supplier consolidation is the process of deliberately shrinking that list back down, and it is one of the more reliable ways to cut spare parts costs without a single price negotiation.


Why a long supplier list costs more than it looks


Every supplier relationship carries fixed costs that have nothing to do with the parts themselves: onboarding, invoicing, minimum order values, separate price lists, separate delivery schedules.

The Hackett Group's benchmarking research found that for every reduction of 2,000 suppliers per billion in spend, companies generate savings of more than 5% of overall procurement costs, driven largely by this kind of administrative overhead rather than unit price alone.


For spare parts specifically, a long tail of rarely used suppliers also tends to correlate with the kind of fragmented, duplicate-prone data we covered in the hidden cost of duplicate spare parts. The same part bought from three different suppliers often ends up recorded as three different parts.


Where consolidation genuinely helps


Consolidation pays off fastest in three situations:


Commodity parts with many qualified suppliers. Bearings, seals, fasteners and similar components are rarely unique to one vendor. Concentrating volume with fewer, better-negotiated suppliers usually lowers unit price and cuts administrative overhead at the same time.


Parts bought once and never reviewed. A supplier used for a single emergency order three years ago, still sitting active in the system, adds complexity without adding value.


Overlapping regional suppliers. Multi-site companies often have each plant sourcing the same part family independently. Consolidating purchasing across sites, even with the same supplier, improves negotiating position.


Where it does not


Consolidation is not free of risk, and treating it as an across-the-board target creates new problems.


Single-source critical parts should not be consolidated onto an already-thin list. If anything, critical spares benefit from a validated second source, not a narrower one.


Specialist and OEM parts rarely have real alternatives. Forcing a captive part through a consolidation exercise usually just means re-signing the same supplier under a different label.


Regional parts with local service requirements often need a local supplier regardless of what the spreadsheet says about volume discounts.


The practical rule: consolidate where parts are interchangeable and volume is real. Leave specialised and safety-critical sourcing alone.


A simple way to start


  1. Pull twelve months of spare parts purchase orders, by supplier and part family.

  2. Flag suppliers used fewer than three times. These are the first candidates for review, not necessarily removal.

  3. Group parts by family, not by supplier, and see how many suppliers currently serve each family.

  4. Check for price spread within a family across suppliers. Wide spread with no quality difference is where consolidation saves the most.

  5. Separate commodity from critical before setting any targets. Different parts need different strategies.


Consolidation needs good data first


Supplier consolidation decisions are only as good as the purchase history behind them, and purchase history is only useful if the same part is recorded consistently across every order.

This is where consolidation projects most often stall: not because the strategy is wrong, but because nobody can confidently say which suppliers actually sell the same part. That is a data problem before it is a negotiation problem, and it is worth solving in that order.


Want to see which of your spare parts suppliers overlap on price? SpareCompare's free Spare Parts Savings Check compares up to 50 of your parts against the market, with results in about a week: https://www.sparecompare.com/spare-parts-savings-check


 
 
 

Kommentarer


bottom of page