top of page

Critical Spare Parts: How to Decide What to Stock and Where to Buy It

Skribentens bild: Laura Andersson
Laura Andersson
9 okt.
4 min läsning
Critical Spare Parts: What to Stock and Where to Buy

Every maintenance team has a short list of parts that keeps people up at night. The gearbox seal with a 14-week lead time. The drive controller only one distributor seems to carry. The sensor that costs €60 but stops a whole line when it fails.


The usual answer is to stock them. Just in case.


That instinct is understandable, and often right. But stocking everything that feels critical ties up capital, and it still leaves gaps, because the list is rarely built on data. Here is a more practical way to decide which critical spare parts to hold, which to source smarter, and where you are probably overpaying.


What makes a spare part critical


Criticality has little to do with the price of the part. A cheap sensor can stop a line as effectively as an expensive motor. Three factors decide it:

  1. Impact of failure. What happens to production, safety or a customer commitment if this part fails and is not available?

  2. Time to replace. How long does it realistically take to get a replacement on site? Use the lead time you actually experience, not the one in the catalog.

  3. Sourcing options. How many suppliers can deliver this part, or a validated equivalent?

Most criticality analyses cover the first two well. The third is the one that gets skipped, and it changes the answer more than most teams expect.


Why the stakes keep rising


Unplanned downtime keeps getting more expensive, raising the stakes on every spare parts decision. Siemens estimates that the world's 500 biggest companies lose almost $1.4 trillion a year to unplanned downtime, equivalent to 11% of their revenues.


The same report found that getting production running again after a stoppage now takes an average of 81 minutes, up from 49 minutes five years earlier. One reason is that emergency replacements have become harder to source and slower to arrive.


For a spare parts manager, that is the key point. When a critical part is missing, the repair clock runs on the supplier's lead time, not on your technician's skill.


A simple criticality matrix


Once each part has an impact score and a sourcing score, most fall into one of four groups:


Easy to source (several suppliers, short lead time)

Hard to source (single source or long lead time)

High impact

Hold a small buffer and agree fast delivery terms

Stock it, and actively develop a second source

Low impact

Do not stock. Buy on demand at the best market price

Stock lightly, or look for an equivalent part

The strategy for each group is different, which is exactly why a single "critical" flag in the ERP is not enough.


The quadrant most teams get wrong


The top-right group, high impact and hard to source, gets most of the attention and most of the budget. It deserves scrutiny, because many parts in it are only single-source on paper.


The OEM part number may have one supplier. The physical component behind it, a standard bearing, seal, valve or sensor, is often made by several manufacturers under different part numbers. Once those equivalents are identified and validated, the part moves to the top-left group: still critical, but no longer hostage to one supplier's stock levels and prices.


That move cuts two costs at once. You can hold less safety stock, because supply is more reliable. And you gain a price reference you never had before. Our guide to OEM vs alternative suppliers covers how to validate an equivalent before switching.


Lead time is a price too


When comparing suppliers for critical spares, the lowest unit price is not always the lowest cost. A part that is 10% cheaper but arrives three weeks later can be the most expensive option on the day it is needed.


For critical spares, compare suppliers on three numbers: unit price, quoted lead time, and how reliably that lead time has actually been met. Logistics teams usually hold the third number. It is worth asking them before the next sourcing decision.


Building your critical spares list in five steps


  1. Start from the assets, not the warehouse. List the equipment where a failure stops production or breaks a customer commitment.

  2. Map the parts to your records. Pull the parts lists for those assets and match them to inventory records. Expect to find the same part under more than one number.

  3. Score every part. Rate impact, real lead time and the number of validated sources. A simple 1 to 3 scale is enough to start.

  4. Cross-reference the single-source parts. Look for equivalents from other manufacturers and second suppliers, then validate them with maintenance.

  5. Set stock levels by group, and review them. Lead times and sources change, so revisit the list at least twice a year.


If you run several sites, add one more step: check whether critical spares can be shared between plants instead of duplicated at each one.


Make the list useful in the field

A critical spares list that lives only in a planning spreadsheet does not help the technician standing in front of a stopped machine. Field supervisors should be able to see which parts are on the list, where they are stocked and which equivalents are approved.

That visibility is part of what decides whether a job is fixed on the first visit, which we explored in our article on first-time fix rates.


Where the savings are


A data-based critical spares review usually saves money in two places. Less capital is tied up in "just in case" stock. And parts that turn out not to be single-source can finally be benchmarked.

That second saving is easy to underestimate. Critical spares are often bought under time pressure, which makes them some of the least benchmarked parts in the catalogue.


SpareCompare typically sees a price gap of 15-30% on common spare parts, and urgency rarely makes that gap smaller.


A critical spares review is also a good example of spare parts intelligence in practice. It draws on parts data, sourcing options, market prices and inventory performance at the same time.


Start with your 50 most critical spare parts. SpareCompare's free Spare Parts Savings Check compares them against current market prices and returns results in about a week: https://www.sparecompare.com/spare-parts-savings-check

 
 
 

Kommentarer


bottom of page